I'll go first — my story

I’ll go first. If I’m asking you to open up here, the least I can do is go first.

I’m Malcolm. I’m the father of three beautiful children — two sons and a daughter. They were taken from me when they were twelve, ten, and eight years old. Through the most extreme, painful and humiliating ordeal imaginable. For the best part of ten years, I fought with everything I had against impossible odds to save our bond. Despite every effort, I lost the battle to remain in their lives.

I was raised in a closed Christian sect. Married young, at twenty-two, as was expected. The marriage was a mismatch from the beginning — two people brought together by shared faith and timing, not by compatibility or real connection. When I started questioning the narrow life the church demanded, things fell apart. I left the sect. My ex-wife stayed. And in their eyes, I became a worldly sinner — a danger to my children’s souls.

What followed was years of hell. Three false accusations of sexual abuse against my own daughter. Arrests. Solitary confinement. Investigations that were eventually all dismissed — every single one — but not before they had destroyed what remained of my bond with my children. The church community turned their backs on me completely. My own brother cut me off. Friends I had loved since childhood refused to speak to me.

The system was painfully slow to understand what was happening. Professionals had no framework for the invisible forces at play — a fundamentalist belief system that saw me as spiritually dangerous, and a mother whose bitterness and fear were systematically turning my children against me.

Eventually, after years of mandated therapy and supervised visits and court battles that cost me tens of thousands, my children — then twelve, ten, and eight — told me they didn’t want to see me anymore. And I had to let them go. Not because I stopped loving them, but because forcing them to come was only increasing their resentment.

That night, something broke inside me. And in the breaking, something unexpected happened. I experienced a flood of unconditional love so powerful it washed away all the bitterness, all the victimhood, all the self-righteousness I had been clinging to. I forgave my ex. I forgave the church. I forgave my children. Not because what they did was right — but because holding onto it was destroying me.

I wrote Love Over Exile because I needed this book to exist when I was in the fire. I couldn’t find anything that was both honest about how devastating this is AND showed that survival — real survival, not just gritting your teeth — was possible.

This community is for all of us who are living through this. You are not alone. I know that sounds hollow when you’re in the thick of it. But I mean it from the bottom of my heart.

Malcolm

Same here, Malcolm. Two years, seven months for me.

God, that bit about setting a place at the table — I still do that too.

Christ, Malcolm. I could have written half of this myself — the “too busy” Saturdays, the stomach aches, even the bit about setting a place at the table.

My lad Jack’s been back in my life three years now (he’s 19), and I still get that punch to the gut reading stories like yours. It doesn’t fully go away, does it? That grief just… sits there.

You did good building this place, mate.

I’ve been sitting here staring at your post for ten minutes, Malcolm, and I keep starting to type then stopping because — Christ, how do you respond to someone laying their soul bare like that?

Two years and four months. I’m at six years with my son Jake. He was eight when it started, fourteen now. Same age as Emma. And reading your words… it’s like looking into a mirror I’ve been avoiding. The way you describe that slow then sudden shift, Emma learning to hate you with precision — I felt that in my chest. Jake used to curl up on the sofa with me reading Harry Potter. Now when he sees me in town he literally crosses the street.

I write too, actually. Started keeping journals when the nights got too long and quiet. Something about putting the words down makes it real but also… bearable somehow? Like I’m documenting that this love existed, still exists, even when there’s nowhere for it to go. Your book — that took guts, mate. To turn this private hell into something that might help the rest of us find our way.

You’re right about needing people who get it. Six years in and I still have mates who think I should “just focus on myself now” like Jake was a hobby I’ve outgrown.

Malcolm, I could have written so much of this myself. The stomach aches before visits, the way they learn exactly which words will wound deepest — I lived through this with my son James nearly fifteen years ago now, and reading your story brought it all flooding back.

What struck me most was your phrase about “living bereavement” — because that’s exactly what this is, isn’t it? The world expects you to grieve a death once and move forward, but this? This is watching your child be slowly erased from your life whilst everyone tells you it’s normal post-divorce adjustment. I spent years thinking I was somehow defective as a mother because James would arrive for contact looking like he’d rather be anywhere else on earth.

Thank you for having the courage to start this. After all these years of silence, it’s extraordinary to find others who understand that particular brand of helplessness when the family courts treat your desperate love as somehow suspicious.

I could have written every word of this myself. Two years, eight months for me.