PA vs estrangement — understanding the difference

Understanding PA
1

This distinction matters — and courts struggle with it enormously. I’ve spent years thinking about it.

Estrangement happens when a child pulls away from a parent because of that parent’s actual behaviour. Maybe the parent was genuinely abusive or neglectful. The child makes their own authentic decision based on real experiences. It’s painful, but it’s their genuine response.

Parental alienation is different. It’s when someone systematically influences a child to reject the other parent without legitimate justification. The child’s rejection isn’t based on their own lived experience but on a narrative that’s been constructed for them.

But here’s where it gets complicated — and this is something I had to face honestly in my own case. PA often includes elements of real conflict. My marriage did fail. I did leave the church. I wasn’t a perfect husband. These were real things my ex could point to.

The difference is proportionality. Did my children’s complete terror of me — their panic attacks asking why I “chose to go to hell” — match anything I actually did? Did their belief that I was a dangerous criminal match the reality that every single allegation was dismissed?

The words my children used didn’t sound like them. They were using adult concepts, church language, phrases they couldn’t possibly have come up with on their own. As one researcher puts it — when a ten-year-old starts parroting their alienating parent’s exact phrases, you’re not hearing the child’s voice anymore.

I’m not saying this to minimise anyone’s genuine failings as a parent. I certainly had mine. But imperfect doesn’t equal deserving complete rejection. And there’s a world of difference between a child who is hurt by something you did and a child who has been systematically taught to fear and despise you.

Understanding this distinction helped me stay focused on what I could control. I couldn’t force my children to see the truth. But I could keep being the father I knew I was — and trust that one day, the truth would find its way to the surface.

Malcolm

Further reading on alienation vs estrangement:

2

This really hit home for me. My ex did exactly the same thing — took the times I’d raised my voice or been stressed after work and turned me into this monster in their heads.

You’re spot on about the proportionality bit. I wasn’t perfect, but suddenly I was supposedly the worst dad in Manchester according to my boys. The gap between reality and what they believed was just mad.

3

I know exactly what you mean about the courts wanting clean categories when the reality is so much more complicated. When my son cut contact five years ago, taking my two grandchildren with him, his wife had done exactly what you describe — taken my real mistakes as a mother-in-law and turned them into evidence that I was toxic and harmful to the children.

Yes, I probably was too involved in their early marriage. Yes, I made comments about parenting choices that weren’t my place. But did that warrant complete banishment from my grandchildren’s lives? The punishment never fitted the crime, if you will.

What strikes me most about your post is that line about proportionality — it’s something I’ve never seen put so clearly before. My grandson used to run to me when I arrived, arms wide open. Now apparently he’s “afraid” of me. That fear doesn’t match anything that actually happened between us, but it’s become his reality through years of careful influence.

The living bereavement of it all remains the same whether we call it PA or estrangement, you’re right about that. But understanding the mechanics has helped me hold onto my sanity these past years.